Link Search Menu Expand Document

Power Stage: MOSFET Selection and Thermal Efficiency

The power stage of the KISRAK-M1 motor driver is a critical component, directly responsible for delivering current to the motor. It utilizes a full H-bridge configuration built with discrete P-Channel (UT2305G) and N-Channel (UTM2054G) MOSFETs. The selection of these specific MOSFETs is driven by a careful balance of performance, efficiency, and cost, with a strong emphasis on minimizing power losses and managing thermal dissipation.

MOSFET Selection Criteria:

  1. Voltage Rating ($V_{DS}$): The drain-source voltage rating must be sufficiently higher than the maximum expected battery voltage to provide a safety margin against voltage spikes and transients. For KISRAK-M1, operating typically from a 1S or 2S LiPo battery (3.7V - 8.4V nominal), MOSFETs with a $V_{DS}$ rating of 20V or 30V are generally suitable. The UT2305G (P-Channel) and UTM2054G (N-Channel) both offer a 20V rating, providing an adequate margin.
  2. Current Rating ($I_D$): The continuous drain current rating must exceed the maximum expected motor current. Micromouse motors can draw significant peak currents during acceleration. The selected MOSFETs offer continuous drain currents (e.g., UT2305G: -4.6A, UTM2054G: 5.3A at $V_{GS}=4.5V$), which are sufficient for typical Micromouse applications, especially when considering the pulsed nature of PWM.
  3. Gate-Source Voltage ($V_{GS}$): The MOSFETs must be fully turned on (saturated) by the gate drive voltage provided by the microcontroller or gate driver. Both selected MOSFETs are “logic-level” compatible, meaning they can be fully turned on with a $V_{GS}$ as low as 2.5V or 4.5V, making them suitable for direct driving from a 3.3V or 5V microcontroller.
  4. Gate Charge ($Q_g$): This parameter is crucial for switching losses. A lower gate charge means less energy is required to charge and discharge the gate capacitance, leading to faster switching times and reduced switching losses, especially at higher PWM frequencies.
  5. On-State Resistance ($R_{DS(on)}$): This is arguably the most critical parameter for thermal efficiency in the power stage.

The Impact of $R_{DS(on)}$ on Thermal Efficiency:

$R_{DS(on)}$ is the resistance between the drain and source terminals of a MOSFET when it is fully turned on. When current flows through the MOSFET in its on-state, power is dissipated as heat due to this resistance. This power loss is calculated by:

\[P_{conduction} = I_D^2 \times R_{DS(on)}\]

Where:

  • $P_{conduction}$ is the power dissipated as heat due to conduction.
  • $I_D$ is the drain current flowing through the MOSFET.
  • $R_{DS(on)}$ is the on-state resistance.

Why lower $R_{DS(on)}$ is crucial:

  • Reduced Heat Generation: A lower $R_{DS(on)}$ directly leads to less power being converted into heat for a given current. This is vital for compact designs like KISRAK-M1, where heat dissipation can be challenging.
  • Improved Efficiency: Less power lost as heat means more power delivered to the motor, increasing the overall efficiency of the motor driver. This translates to longer battery life and better performance.
  • Prevention of Thermal Runaway: Excessive heat can increase $R_{DS(on)}$ (for N-channel MOSFETs, $R_{DS(on)}$ typically increases with temperature), leading to a positive feedback loop where more heat generates more resistance, leading to even more heat. This can eventually destroy the MOSFET. Selecting MOSFETs with very low $R_{DS(on)}$ helps mitigate this risk.
  • Smaller Heatsinking Requirements: With less heat generated, the need for large heatsinks or extensive copper pours for thermal dissipation is reduced, allowing for a more compact PCB design.

Selected MOSFETs:

  • P-Channel MOSFET (High-Side): UT2305G
    • $V_{DS}$: -20V
    • $I_D$: -4.6A
    • $R_{DS(on)}$: 45mΩ @ $V_{GS}=-4.5V$, 65mΩ @ $V_{GS}=-2.5V$
    • Datasheet: UT2305G Datasheet
  • N-Channel MOSFET (Low-Side): UTM2054G
    • $V_{DS}$: 20V
    • $I_D$: 5.3A
    • $R_{DS(on)}$: 25mΩ @ $V_{GS}=4.5V$, 35mΩ @ $V_{GS}=2.5V$
    • Datasheet: UTM2054G Datasheet

The chosen MOSFETs offer a good balance of low $R_{DS(on)}$ for their package size (SOT-23), sufficient current and voltage ratings, and logic-level compatibility, making them ideal for the KISRAK-M1’s high-performance, compact design. The difference in $R_{DS(on)}$ between P-channel and N-channel MOSFETs is typical, as P-channel devices generally have higher on-resistance for a given die size due to the lower mobility of holes compared to electrons. This is why N-channel MOSFETs are preferred for low-side switching where possible.